Chaeronea 338 BC - Macedonians vs Thebans and Allies

-

Last Saturday saw the 'Old Berks' reconvene for a WAB 1.5 game.  This time another Greek vs Macedonian battle; very loosely based on Chaeronea.

From the battle-map below, you can see that the Greeks had proportionally more cavalry and skirmishers than they may have had in the real battle.


Phil and Steve paired up as the Macedonians and John and I as the Greeks.  We are still getting familiar with the rules so, this time, introduced a modest amount of scenery to see how that played out.

I'd decided that I'd been too cautious in recent games, so the Greeks - perhaps uncharacteristically - engaged the Macedonians on both flanks.  A rather stupid decision on my part saw us concede the initiative at the start, but, fortunately, this was compensated for by the oracle rolls: 3 for the Macedonians and 8 for the Greeks. This helped us considerably in the forthcoming battle.

Unlike the original battle, the Theban Sacred Band survived.  However, in our version, they didn't even make contact.

The initial dispositions - from the Greek left.

...and from the Greek right.

We deployed the hoplites (3 units) in ranks of 3.  Although not strictly Theban (the later armies were famed for their very deep formations), I was interested to see if the wider frontage helped narrow the odds against the Macedonian pike phalanxes.  Two units had heavy armour which gave a 3+ saving throw, but made the advance painfully slow due to the extra armour reducing their movement

The Theban Sacred Band (centre) flanked by 2 hoplite units.

Eventually the centres did collide (well, 2 units did).  With the one hoplite unit 'bouncing' a pike unit.

Skirmishers on both sides had an interesting battle.  Greek javelinmen on the left flank chased off and eventually routed a Macedonian Hipparch and his accompanying Thessalians, whereas on the other flank the Agrianians held (and were whittling down) the Theban heavy cavalry.

Greek peltasts and Macedonian skirmishers contest the woods.

Greek HC cavalry chase off Macedonian peltasts, whilst completely ignoring the Thessalians right next to them!

The Greeks took back the hill and the woods after initial Macedonian advances.  However, the Companions made an appearance on the hill shortly after.

Roughly the midway point of the battle.

View from behind the Greek lines.  Now there's space, the Inn of the Prancing Peltast (and its vineyard) could make an appearance!



Final turn - the Macedonian right had disappeared whilst the left was contested.  The Greeks had more units there, but the Agrianians were tying up the Theban heavy cavalry and Alexander had surged forward with the Companions and routed a unit of peltasts. 2 more turns would, potentially, have seen the rolling up of the Macedonian centre.

A great game.  More rules learnt and tested.  I think we spent as much time chatting and planning our next ventures as we did playing.  But that's all part of the fun!

The now obligatory Old Berks photo.  From left: John, Andy, Steve & Phil.

Some further photos from the battle.

Copyright

Please note: 
All images and text are copyright Andrew Moran and must not be reproduced in any form without the author's express permission. Thank you.

Comments

  1. John Kersey6 July 2022 at 13:38

    Great write up Andy. I think Phil called it as a victory for the Greeks! As for the Companions they had taken losses and there were still two viable units on their flank before they got to the Macedonoan centre. My intention was to kamikaze charge them into the Companions to at least halt them!

    ReplyDelete
  2. AndyM7 July 2022 at 07:23

    Thanks, John. A kamikaze charge, eh? :-D

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Onomarchos versus Philip of Macedon

-
Image
 Warhammer Ancient Battles (WAB) - Phocian Greek versus Rise of Macedon Army - September 2021 View from the Macedonian right flank.  Note the sacrificing priest. So...time for the return match. Philip of Macedon and his young, upstart son, Prince Alexander, were out to teach those impious, temple-robbing Phocians and their over-paid mercenaries a lesson! I've always liked the idea of a Phocian army (that, or a Syracusan) since my WRG 6th Edition days.  Here was a chance to actually use one (using the list from the Alexander the Great WAB supplement). Again, we opted for no scenery - just an open plain so that we could focus on learning the rules. DISASTER STRIKES! However, the night before I did something really, really stupid.  Doing production-line varnishing, I put a tray of freshly sprayed Phocian Epilektoi onto the top of the washing machine.  It hadn't clicked with me that the machine was on.  I left them there while it went through a spin cycle! I he...
Read more

Scenery - The Inn of the Prancing Peltast

-
Image
Further to it's first appearance on the battlefield during our most recent battle (it was placed behind the Greek lines once the troops had moved forward enough), here are soon more photos of the recently-painted inn (or kapeleion ).  I had a lot of pleasure painting and basing this resin model.  I've had it at least 10-15 years, I think.  In fact, I may have bought it with Peninsular Wargaming in mind! Here's the inn sign - proof that it's a 'Prancing Peltast'! And here are the neighbouring vineyard and olive grove (more olive trees on order). Greek light cavalry hurry past the inn. Athenian hoplites take up position in front of the inn. There's a small barley/wheat field to follow in the future.  I am determined that the inn will be a self-sufficient business! Copyright Please note:  All images and text are copyright Andrew Moran and must not be reproduced in any form without the author's express permission. Thank you.
Read more

Straw Dogs & Flaming Bulls

-
Image
The inaugural meeting of the 'Old Berks' (Phil lives near Berkswell, so the name just suggested itself!) took place at Partizan three weeks before.  We all met last weekend to have our first game.   So, the historical context for the battle (and don't tell me this never happened): after India, the Macedonians with Greek mercenaries pushed on into China, and there they met - amongst other things - Straw Dogs and Flaming Bulls! John brought hordes (?) of excellent Chinese Warring States troops, which he and Steve commanded.   John, incidentally, is the author of the excellent WAB supplement, The Art of War (above).  Knowing very little about ancient Chinese armies, I have found this an instructive and entertaining read.  My opponent had no excuse for not knowing his troops.   But, John, you still haven't signed my copy! No detailed battle map this time folks.  It was 3000 points aside (1500 per commander), so you'll see from the accompanying photos that...
Read more